• Sign In
  • Create an Account
US
UK
Toggle Nav
My Cart
Search
Menu
Account

20% off sitewide** with code: SAVE20

Personalized Gifts for Ages 1-3 Years

Personalized Gifts for Ages 1-3 Years

Personalized toddler gifts

Create a gift that’s just as special as your little one! Our personalized toddler gifts are a fun introduction to reading and make treasured keepsakes.

Items 1-20 of 111

Page
per page
Set Descending Direction
  1. Curious George Plush
    Curious George Plush
    $14.99
  2. ’Twas the Night before Christmas on Sesame Street! and Elmo Plush Personalized Gift Set
    ’Twas the Night Before Christmas on Sesame Street and Elmo Gift Set
    $48.99 Reg $54.98
    View
  3. Don't Shake the Present Personalized Book
    Don't Shake the Present!
    2 Reviews
    As low as $24.99
    View
  4. I Love You So Much Gift Set
    I Love You So Much Gift Set
    $48.99 Reg $54.98
    View
  5. Welcome Little One Personalized Book
    Lots of Love Little You
    As low as $24.99
    View
  6. Be Brave Little One and Cozy Dog Plush Gift Set
    Be Brave Little One and Cozy Dog Plush Gift Set
    Rating:
    100%
    1 Review
    $41.99 Reg $46.98
    View
  7. Hooray For You! Personalized Book
    Hooray For You!
    Rating:
    100%
    6 Reviews
    As low as $24.99
    View
  8. I Love You So Personalized Board Book
    I Love You So... – Board Book Edition
    Rating:
    100%
    1 Review
    $29.99
    View
  9. I Love You So Much Personalized Board Book
    I Love You So Much... – Board Book Edition
    Rating:
    100%
    1 Review
    $29.99
    View
  10. Lots of Love Little You and Cozy Elephant Plush Gift Set
    Lots of Love Little You and Cozy Elephant Plush Gift Set
    $48.99 Reg $54.98
    View
  11. More Bears! and Philbin Teddy Bear Plush Gift Set
    More Bears! and Philbin Teddy Bear Plush Gift Set
    $48.99 Reg $54.98
    View
  12. Your First Book of Bedtime Rhymes Personalized Board Book
    Your First Book of Bedtime Rhymes – Board Book Edition
    $29.99
    View
  13. Don't Push the Button Personalized Board Book
    Don't Push the Button! – Board Book Edition
    $29.99
    View
  14. Good Night to You and Teddy Bear Personalized Gift Set
    Good Night to You and Teddy Bear Gift Set
    $48.99 Reg $54.98
    View
  15. Your Magical Unicorn Day and Dreaming of You Unicorn Gift Set
    Your Magical Unicorn Day and Dreaming of You Unicorn Gift Set
    $48.99 Reg $54.98
    View
  16. Bedtime Blessings and Teddy Bear Personalized Gift Set
    Bedtime Blessings and Teddy Bear Gift Set
    $48.99 Reg $54.98
    View
  17. Your First Book of Animal Rhymes Personalized Board Book
    Your First Book of Animal Rhymes – Board Book Edition
    $29.99
    View
  18. I Love You So Deluxe and Teddy Bear Gift Set
    I Love You So Deluxe and Teddy Bear Gift Set
    $52.99 Reg $59.98
    View
  19. Winky Lamb and Blanket Set
    Winky Lamb and Blanket Set
    $36.99
    Out of stock
  20. Good Night to You Personalized Book
    Good Night to You
    51 Reviews
    As low as $24.99
    View

Items 1-20 of 111

Page
per page
Set Descending Direction
Change Store:
US
UK
Terms & Conditions:

* Free standard shipping is valid on U.S. orders over $65.00 and Canadian orders over $100.00 (USD). Total is based on amount due before tax and after promotional offers or discounts are applied. Valid only for Standard Economy shipping. No code is necessary for this offer. Certain restrictions may apply. Click here for details.


** Use coupon code SAVE20 at checkout to take advantage of this offer and receive 20% off sitewide. Valid only on personalized books and gift sets priced $19.99 and higher. Offer excludes eBooks, "Seen Us in a Store?" books, non-personalized books, and LEGO® activity packs. Order totals are calculated before shipping and tax. Discount will be applied at checkout. No cash value. Coupon only redeemable one time per transaction. Offer cannot be combined with any other discounts or promotions. Offer is valid for a single order to a single shipping address. This offer expires 8/31/20 at 11:59 p.m. CT.


Offers are subject to change without notice. Put Me In The Story reserves the right to modify or cancel any offer at any time.


We have made updates to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy as of June 1, 2018 to give you more control over your personal information, support new data protection laws in the European Union called the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR), and allow you to make more informed privacy choices when you interact with us.

Privacy Policy | Terms Of Use
All content and design copyright © Put Me In The Story 2020. All Rights Reserved.